Download a Permanent Printable PDF Version of This Article.
December 17, 2016
The Church was intended to last, unchanged, until the end of time. Reason, reflection and intuition seem to point to the existence of the possibility to correct and redirect the Church when it goes off the rails. Even Popes are only human, after all. Bishops correct us when we fail; they correct each other when they fail. Matthew gives us the formula:
But what if this situation applies to a Pope?
Look back through the long history of the Papacy and you will see that, yes, Popes have been deposed, under all sorts of questionable circumstances involving everything from heresy to internal politics, of all things. I knew that we have had bad Popes, but one might have hoped that the Bishops of the Catholic Church would be above political intrigues and plots. With exceptions here and there, of course, since they, too, are humans. But, go through it yourself, and you might be surprised, as I was, at all the political shenanigans.
What's prompting ordinary Catholic laymen and American Constitutionalist "Deplorables" like me to look back at all this Church History is the successful efforts of Pope Francis to "Make A Mess" and establish chaos and disorder where there was previously a sense of normalcy and good order in our Catholic thinking. Confusion, in other words, on vitally important matters concerning the souls of men. Opposition to and even destruction of Catholic Clarity on long established and previously perfectly clear Catholic Doctrine.
We talked about this recently in Dubiosity, where we addressed the five Dubia (Doubts) sent by four Cardinals as simple yes or no questions to Pope Francis for official clarification of his teaching in paragraph eight of his Amoris Laetitia. Going to the pertinent paragraphs in that chapter, and taking the words there in their literal and contextual meaning, we even answered them ourselves, quite easily. But all the answers appeared to be in direct violation of long established doctrine and Revealed Truth. Thus, you can see the confusion here.
Previous to this seemingly purposeful confusion displacing clarity, we have questioned Pope Francis' seeming affection for Marxist global ideologies, despite the condemnation of past Popes and Councils. In our book, Culture=Religion+Politics, in multiple webpages on this website and in multiple interviews, we have sought clarification and full understanding of his clearly Marxist interpretation of "Social Justice" as opposed to the interpretation of his predecessors.
It isn't merely simple lay Deplorables like me who are seeking clarity here. The whole Church is now in disarray over the five doubts and the Pope's refusal to respond to them. Cardinals and Bishops all over the world are divided on it and pointing condemning fingers at each other over it.
These two positions cannot both be correct; one must be wrong.
Bishop Athanasius Schneider has issued a letter in strong support of the Prophetic Voice of Four Cardinals who sent the Dubia to His Holiness.
In the face of that, Austen Ivereigh, a London-based Catholic journalist, author and commentator, charged the four Cardinals, and all who agreed with them, with being dissenters and Schismatics, charging them with seeking to overturn doctrine rather than clarifying it. ???
Michael Voris at Church Militant weighed in on that example of pseudo-intellectual Leftism, with a new (to me) abbreviated idiom: IYI, which stands for Intellectual Yet Idiotic. I like it so much I may add it to all the site hover links, found at the bottom of this and every other article on this site.
There are just so many potential applications, as we look around our culture today. Stephen Hawking comes to mind, as a recognized world-class scientific genius, yet so absolutely convinced, with no supporting scientific evidence whatsoever, of the "unsustainability" of life on earth that he is recommending the colonization of Mars or the Moon to preserve humankind. Quick, while we still can.
Intellectual Yet Idiotic certainly applies to IYI Stephen Hawking.
Cardinal Burke himself defended the Dubia signers with alacrity in an EWTN interview. Everything written and said by Cardinal Burke and the other signers seems quite reasonable, respectful and measured, and precisely what is called for in such a situation of a glaringly obvious lack of clarity.
Francis Responds to the Dubia?
At a site I am unfamiliar with, it is purported that Pope Francis has responded to the Dubia. Thus far I have not been able to find any other source backing this up, so I don't know if it's true or not.
This response, as some sort of an informal response to criticism, is not a formal response to the signers of the Dubia, and so I don't know what kind of weight to give it. But the interesting thing about it is, he answered each of the five questions exactly as I answered them, in the comments after Dubiosity, with a qualification for each answer. As in:
So, I am left to wonder, is anything at all black and white?
I can easily imagine that "Catholics" such as John Kerry, Nancy Pelosi, Joe Biden, etc., might "discern" the answers to these doubts somewhat differently than you and me, and Card. Burke.
I don't know about you, but I'm confused here, and I don't think I should be confused at all. Provided that sexual immorality is evil, with no shades of gray, then things such as adultery and homosexuality are of the devil. Unless they are not. Which raises the original Baptismal question of all Catholics, once again:
Do you renounce Satan and all his evil works? Yes or no.
Somebody help me out here. Is that question black and white, or not?
Smart-Assed Acronym Hover-Link Footnotes: For the convenience of those readers using devises that lack a mouse, these footnotes are provided for all webpages, in case any webpage contains any hover-links. (If you don't have a mouse, you can't "hover" it over a link without clicking just to see the simple acronym interpretation.)SLIMC1 Secularist Liberal Intellectual Media Complex
Culture=Religion+Politics; Who Are We? Vic Biorseth
The Brilliantly Conceived Organization of the USA; Vic Biorseth
Return to the BLOG page
Return to the HOME PAGE
Respond to This Article Below The Last Comment
If you want to build a website like this one, this is how you do it.
Never be lukewarm.
Life itself demands passion.
He who is indifferent to God has already forfeited his soul.
He who is indifferent to politics has already forfeited his liberty.
In America, religion is not mere window dressing and citizenship is not a spectator sport.
Do not allow our common destiny as a whole people to just happen without your input.
Catholic American Thinker
Free E-zine Subscription
You will receive immediate email newsletters with links to new articles as they are published here. Your email is perfectly secure here; we use it only to send you the
Catholic American Thinker
and absolutely nothing else.
The Purpose of this grouping of links is to organize all site Papal Imperfection webpages in one place for easier reference.
Papal Imperfection Pages.
While Popes enjoy the charism of Infallibility when teaching on faith and morals, as established in the unchanging Deposit of Faith, they remain human, and imperfect, as was Peter and the original Apostles. Popes can err when not teaching on faith and morals, and whenever speaking on matters outside the Deposit of Faith. Two of these areas, particularly troubling in these days, involve Papal favor shown to areas of Godless Marxist ideology, and to the belligerent, invasive, domineering and menacing false religion of Islam.
Who will drain the Catholic Swamp, and how, exactly? Trump is draining the Washington Swamp; what about the Catholic Swamp? Our last perfectly capable Pope abdicated for apparent political reasons, certainly not health. Was he Swamped?
Will Pope Francis become a Self Deposing Pope? "The pope himself, if notoriously guilty of heresy, would cease to be pope because he would cease to be a member of the Church."--Catholic Encyclopedia
Red Pope Francis and the KGB's Liberation Theology. The Russian KGB developed "Liberation Theology" as another path to Global Revolution. Pope Francis may be a victim of it, or, he may be a perpetrator of it.
Vatican War: Are we witnessing a Papal Melt Down? Pope Francis and the "Spirit Of Vatican II" Cardinals now openly attacking Orthodox Cardinals in the now open-to-public-view Vatican War.
On the Question of Papal Deposability. Asking whether Bishops may actually Depose a Pope for Heresy. Is there even such a thing as Papal Deposability?
Dubiosity (my word) in Francis' Papacy: The Five Dubia. Pope Francis feeds Papal Dubiosity through indecisiveness, vague language and official pronouncements left open to wildly varying interpretation.
Pope Francis and the deepening and worsening Catholic Civil War. Letter asking Pope Francis to step down: Can we really do that? Has it been done before? And is Pope Francis even Catholic?
There is No Hell, because Pope Francis said so. Right? "No one can be condemned for ever, because that is not the logic of the Gospel!" --Pope Francis
Popephobia: A Catholic Mental Disorder. (I think I have it.) Popephobia is related to American Obamaphobia, and German Merkelphobia. They are all closely related social disorders. (Could they be a Social WMD?)
The Blind Guides leading Western Civilization toward the pit of Human Barbarity. "Establishment" Party Members and "Establishment" USCCB Bishops are not all Evil Traitors; most of them are Deceived Blind Guides.
Unreason in the Church: Who Is Evangelizing Who? On Unreasoned Gathering with Sinners: Who is Converting Who? Is the Church committing "Merciful" Suicide?
Loosey-Goosey Theology, Wishy-Washy Leadership, and Anything Goes Culture. Pope Francis' Exhortation, Obamunist Cultural Diversity, LGBTQP+ "Sophisticated" Social Engineering, and "Whatever" Global Culture.
Why Did Vatican II Ignore Communism? The veil of mystery over the Council’s omitting any reference to Communism has gradually been lifted
I must oppose the pope on globalism, but not on faith and morals. Recent comments of the pope on globalism, calling for a world political authority, is absolutely the last thing the world needs.
The Smoke of Satan is in the Church in America; has it reached the Vatican too? The Smoke of Satan conceals the true object of the Progressive Agenda.
On the "inevitability" of a Perfect Global Government in a "New World Order". Is this "New World Order" idea divinely inspired, or is it the ongoing work of Satan?
Pope Francis, Evangelii Gaudium, and Evangelizing for World Communism. Evangelii Gaudium started out on Catholic Evangelism, but ended up Evangelizing World Communism.
The Treacherous Global Delusions of Marxism-Leninism. Is Pope Francis a duped "Useful Idiot" of Marxism, is he Delusional, or is he actually In On It?
Musings on the deep treachery of the most trusted among us. Deep Treachery: Were they all deceiving us from the beginning, or did they somehow "turn" after being raised to positions of trust?
Crony-Catholicism? Really? The USCCB is advancing Obamunism? Say it ain't so, Joe! It's bad enough that we now have so many Marxified Bishops, but now they actually act against the faith?
Cliff Kincaid interviewed Vic on TV about Pope Francis and his Marxism. Addressing Marxist and Islamic ideology creeping into Catholicism.
If Francis is a Communist Pope, how does that affect Catholic Faith and Morals? Exploring the links between Comrade Obama (peace be upon him), Pope Francis and Communist Cuba.
Roman Catholic Marxism? Excuse me? Who is evangelizing whom? Roman Catholic Marxism explores the Politics of Private property v. Collective property (i.e., Marxist Redistributionism.)
On the Vague Anti Authoritarianism of Pope Francis And the Relationship between Vague Anti Authoritarianism in High Places and Moral Depravity in Culture
Do we have an anti-American Pope? A Pro-Obama, Anti-Capitalist, Redistributionist, Utopian, Pro-Illegal Alien, quite consistently Anti-American, Pope Francis?
Delusional Pope Francis, molding world culture into one undefinable hodgepodge. Does the Pope want International Communism, or just a border-less, all inclusive, nonsensical, global non-culture?
The Religion Politics Nexus: If the Religion is not true, Politics become evil. For Martin Luther, Politics drove Religion. For Pope Francis, Religion drives Politics. Or does it?
Pope Francis just said WHAT? Excuse me? Can anyone out there help me reconcile what Pope Francis just said with Catholic Revealed Truth?
Marxists running the Vatican's Pontifical Academy of Social Science? Died in the wool Marxists in the Vatican's P.A.S.S. No wonder Pope Francis favors the Socializing Frauds of "Sustainable Development", "Climate Change", etc.
Disorder and Confusion from the White House. And from the Vatican, too? The growing disorder in Obama's America, and in Pope Francis' Catholic Church.
Pope Francis receives an Open Letter calling for his Papal Resignation. "Year of Mercy" begins with an Open Letter: An Urgent Appeal to Pope Francis to Either Change Course or Renounce the Petrine Office.
Globalist Pope Francis' Marxist Program to End All Sovereign Nations. Our Globalist Pope leads the attack on all National Sovereignty to bring an end to all national borders in favor of Total Global Disorder, ostensibly for the good of the Planet and the Poor.
Looking more closely at Pope Francis' chosen Papal Pals. If a critter walks like a duck, talks like a duck and is constantly seen in the company of other ducks, the logical conclusion is that he most probably is a duck.
Globalist Stupidassism in the Vatican. Globalist Fraud after Hoax after Scam, all promoted in the Pontifical Academy of Science and the Pontifical Academy of Social Sciences "Workshop on Biological Extinction."
On the new (to me) heresy of Popalitry. False belief that a Pope can do no wrong leads to Pope Worship.
Do we have a Diabolically Controlled Pope? Every time he opens his mouth, he makes himself a fool.
The Dubia Aftermath shows that Pope Francis still doesn't get it. Non-response to the Dubia means a Warning; non-response to that means a second Warning, and finally, a non-Pope Council to depose the Pope.
"We belong to the Church militant; and She is militant because on earth the powers of darkness are ever restless to encompass Her destruction. Not only in the far-off centuries of the early Church, but down through the ages and in this our day, the enemies of God and Christian civilization make bold to attack the Creator’s supreme dominion and sacrosanct human rights.”--Pope Pius XII
"It is not lawful to take the things of others to give to the poor. It is a sin worthy of punishment, not an act deserving a reward, to give away what belongs to others."--St. Francis of Assisi
If you can't find the page you're looking for, try the