Download a Permanent Printable PDF Version of This Article.
The Haditha "incident" occurred November 19, 2005; it involved an IED (Improvised Explosive Device) attack on Marines, followed up by AK-47 small arms fire from a house. The Marine response was aggressive; Marines tend to be aggressive, and their ROE (Rules Of Engagement) are, in these circumstances, quite aggressive. Results of the engagement were four armed insurgents killed, and 15 civilians killed, in the house from which the initial small arms fire came, and another house through which the insurgents fled. The investigation proved that the Marines followed precisely the rules of engagement and that the civilians were victims of collateral damage on the hot battlefield, and certainly not executed or even knowingly or willingly killed by Marines. And there was no cover-up, by anyone. The entire incident was reported immediately. Marines remained on the scene for many hours after the incident, helping with removal and identification of the dead.I'll bet you didn't hear any of that from the SLIMC1 . The March 27 Time Magazine reported that the Marines at Haditha just barged into private homes, throwing grenades and shooting innocent people who were cowering in fear. Another completely false MSM "News" report; so what else is new? But then, the yellow-bellied cut-and-runner, Rep. John Murtha (D. PA) jumped in with his own imaginative version, declaring that the "true" story, of which he was privy, was that even more innocent civilians had been murdered than were reported by Time. He stated flatly that the United States Marines had "killed innocent civilians in cold blood." Which turns out to have been, of course, a flagrant categorical lie. Which makes Murtha a flagrant categorical liar, doesn't it. He also flatly stated that "there was no firefight." Another lie. Now that the investigation is complete, there will be no further comment from him, or from the rest of the SLIMC1 .
In other news, we learn that the bodies of the two recently captured Screaming Eagles of the famous 101st Airborne division have been recovered by their brothers near the town of Youssifiyah, south of Baghdad. And, it turns out again, as it always does, that the Islamic enemy holds to no recognizable moral standard, and certainly no international standards regarding either warfare or treatment of POWs. These young warriors had been tortured before being murdered, and their bodies were mutilated.More silence from the SLIMC1 . Not a peep out of Amnesty International. The Leftie Dems who foam at the mouth over a stain on the kid-glove of the hand that gives a Koran to one of the Islamic bloody butchers in Gitmo have nothing to say about tortured, murdered and mutilated American POWs. Perhaps the cat has their tongues.
John Flipflop/Turncoat Kerry authored a bill requiring US forces to cut-and-run by the end of the year, but he didn't have the guts to submit it for a vote, so someone else did. It lost, by 93 to 6. Let me guess who some of the six might be: Teddy "Iraq is (hic) another Vietnam (hic)" Kennedy; Johnny "If you don't believe ... Saddam Hussein is a threat with nuclear weapons, then you shouldn't vote for me" Kerry; John "We can't win this militarily" Murtha. Kerry's (and Feingold's) new cut-and-run date is now supposed to be July 1, 2007. All the Democrats are, in fact, quite ready to wave the white flag in Iraq.
Just in case his next cut-and-run date doesn't make it either, Kerry is now calling for high level, international negotiations with the terrorists, no doubt over cocktails, with the negotiators to include, besides Al Qaeda, terrorist countries like Syria and Iran. And probably France. I wouldn't be surprised if he were already secretly talking to the bad guys, just as he talked to his buddies, the Viet Cong, during the Vietnam War, behind his nations back.
What's really motivating the Dems and all other Lefties and Marxists with a political or media public voice, is the growing recognition of the distinct possibility of an actual increase in real, actual, Democracy in the world. That's what they can't stand, and what really has them all in a lather. In the Marxist view, the socio-political wave of the future should always be Marxism, not Democracy. Even the so-called centrist Dems know that. Newly centrist Madame Hillary even wrote a best seller on it, titled It Takes A Commune To Raise A Child, remember? Excuse me, did I say Commune? I meant to say Village.
As you can see in the Islam and the Jews page, Democracy, and every other form of government or law other than the Islamic Sharia, is strictly against the religion of Islam. And yet, the people of Iraq, overwhelmingly, voted themselves into a new Democracy. However imperfect, however shaky and wobbly its first steps, however risky, however at odds with its nearest neighbors, it is a newborn representative Democracy, and the Iraqi people have spoken. And this was not a small majority, by any means. As time goes on, if it survives its first years of existence, Iraqi freedom can only grow stronger, and, there is this: freedom is infectious. Freedom's flag, and representative Democracy, is now sprouting right in the middle of a bunch of Islamic dictatorships.
As I said in the Islam and the Jews page, to the degree that Islamic people move toward and into representative Democracy, to that same degree do they move out of and away from the way of Islam, which cannot, and dares not, allow the citizen, in his majority, to become the sovereign. Without promoting any other religion, Democracy, in and of itself, imposes a certain degree of separation between ecclesial government and civil government. Civil government must be secular, and not religious, for Democracy to work. We can only pray that Iraqi government never becomes secularist, as ours has. Civil government being free of religious rules does not mean civil government flatly opposing and suppressing any particular religion, as pure secularism demonstrably does in America.
It may take many generations, and it may never perfectly happen, but if freedom lives long enough in that area of the world, the form and function of Islam practiced by what increasingly become sovereign citizens will, I predict, move away from notions of Islamic world domination and conquest by the sword, and toward a more civil, more tranquil, more peaceful era of prosperity, brotherhood, neighborliness and coming together in the open world marketplace. Bush was and is right, in more ways than one. Democracies, as a rule, do not make war on each other. And, Democracy, as a rule, is a voluntarily accepted majority-rule force that can temper if not eventually destroy the most hateful, destructive, warlike and freedom-limiting aspects of Islam.
All the people in that part of the world are God's children, too. They have much the same wants and needs, emotions, hopes and dreams as anyone else. Their individual and collective behavior is largely a product of their culture, their up-bringing and their faith. As we watch their individual and collective conditions improve under Democracy, we should take lessons from it, and do whatever we can to stop the decline in our own Democratic progress and our own Judeo-Christian morality.
Now, the gorgeous talking heads of the MSM and pundits of the Leftist Press will accentuate the negative and eliminate the positive from all reporting on Iraq, and on Afghanistan. They will insist that we are losing, and cannot win, and that we should cut and run. And, they will insist that no one, no one, can criticize the likes of Murtha and Kerry, because they are decorated veterans.
Maybe they were decorated, but that was then and this is now. And, it may be argued, Kerry, and no one else, decorated Kerry. Benedict Arnold was, without question, a decorated American hero. He was also a turncoat and a traitor, just like Kerry, and, probably, just like Murtha.
Iraq needs our support, now more than ever. The overwhelming
majority of the Iraqi people do not deserve to be deserted in their hour
of need, as were the South Vietnamese people in the disgraceful Congressionally required American cut-and-run that ended the Vietnam War and significantly advanced the cause of the International Communist movement.
Smart-Assed Acronym Hover-Link Footnotes: For the convenience of those readers using devises that lack a mouse, these footnotes are provided for all webpages, in case any webpage contains any hover-links. (If you don't have a mouse, you can't "hover" it over a link without clicking just to see the simple acronym interpretation.)SLIMC1 Secularist Liberal Intellectual Media Complex
Culture=Religion+Politics; Who Are We? Vic Biorseth
The Brilliantly Conceived Organization of the USA; Vic Biorseth
Return to the BLOG page
Return to the HOME PAGE
Respond to This Article Below The Last Comment
Date: Mon Apr 04 10:55:32 2011
I think you are getting a bit starry-eyed over the soldiers. When the "young warriors of the famous 101st Airborne division" were found, there was also a slip of paper which said that this was done to avenge Abeer Hamza and her family. Perhaps you should read about what happened to her. Of course, torturing enemy combatants goes against every convention, treaty, or basic humanity, but rage can dull your eyes. The unfortunate US soldiers were not guilty, and the real culprits were later punished, but you cannot expect enemy to make that distinction. It is, as you say, "collateral damage."
Among the 15 civilians killed in Haditha, 4 were children. How do you explain that away? You look before you shoot, right? Trying to explain all that away as just "typical marine aggressive reaction" is bit far-fetched.
Like it or not, Vic, the fact remains that most soldiers are not the brightest pennies around. Most of them are barely 20 year old kids, ill-educated, with delusions of being young Omar Bradleys. So Hadithas and Abeer Hamsas will continue to happen, and so will the bloodiness of Iraqis when they get their grubby hands on one of the soldiers. No offense, just a fact.
Date: Mon Apr 04 11:22:35 2011
From: Vic Biorseth
You’re right; we cannot expect Moslems to make any distinction between innocence or guilt, a soldier or a civilian, a warrior or an ordinary citizen, or any other distinction that any normal civilized man would make. Moslems are uncivilized. They are barbarians. The conventions, treaties and so forth that you mention do not apply to non-uniformed terrorists any more than they apply to pirates or non-uniformed spies. American soldiers are being far too kind to take any of them alive.
Why should I explain four dead children in a battle? You should explain it. Moslems don’t give a damn about collateral damage and you know it, so stop pretending.
You are way off on the quality of American fighting men today. All of them are volunteers, and I would wager that the average 20 year old American Marine is better educated than you are, and that he will kick your Moslem ass, and your ass alone, if you don’t run and hide among women and children like a yellow coward.
Date: Tue Apr 05 00:35:43 2011
Wow Wow Wow,
For all this bluster, I find it amusing that you have not cared to mention Abeer Hamza. Cannot explain that away, can you, because THE MARINE PLED GUILTY AS CHARGED. So that cannot be leftie newspaper delusion.
I am not muslim. I am a Hindu Brahmin, as I think I have already written once.
Date: Tue Apr 05 06:24:35 2011
From: Vic Biorseth
Never mistake a straight on statement of fact for bluster. This article was about the false reporting, politicizing and political posturing regarding the fire fight at Haditha. You have already stated that Abeer Hamza had nothing whatsoever to do with the murdered paratroopers, or with the Haditha story, so why should I explain it? Is there any other incident anywhere else on earth you feel that I should explain here for some reason?
Please forgive my mistake; your many earlier submissions on multiple pages have left me confused as to which one of your hidden personalities you might be. I recall that you signed one of your submissions after the Eco-Nazi Movement page thus:
At least one of those bogus personalities identified himself as a Moslem. You are supposed to be working on a dissertation or master’s thesis or something, if anything you say can be taken as true, but I’ll tell you this. I have had to correct multiple gross miss-spellings on every single one of your submissions to this website. If any American soldier or Marine did not possess a better education than you have demonstrated in these pages he would not be an American soldier or Marine. You quite clearly do not know whereof you speak.
Date: Tue Apr 05 10:07:59 2011
Again the perfect example of the bluster and stupidities I have come to expect from you. I opposed your whitewashing the crimes committed by marines. My education has nothing whatsoever to do with it. But if you care to know, English is the language I speak and write LEAST fluently, because it is not my mother tongue. You are the example of the typical American idiot who thinks that your peculiar brand of English is the only language in the globe. But that is beside the point. Had you been born in Iraq, I promise you Vic, that you would have been a great mullah. You have the same idiotic fanatical mentality.
Waiting for your spittle-flying fury and choice nonsense to unleash itself.
Date: Wed Apr 06 05:59:51 2011
From: Vic Biorseth
My my; I seem to have touched a nerve.
If English is so unimportant in your life, and if English is so unimportant in the larger world, then why did you bother to learn it, why do they even teach it in your country, and why are we even having this conversation?
Now, in a submission from April 4, 2011 on the Cut Dept of Education page you indicated that you had read all of these pages and presented me with the left-handed compliment that I am “not an idiot.” But here, after you have been identified as a semi-literate, you are so stung by that criticism as to label me a typical American idiot.
I wish you would calm down a bit and try to make up your tiny little mind.
Are all Americans idiots, or just me?
And why did you even seek out my idiotic website in the first place?
PS: You really should invest in a spell checker.
Date: Tue Apr 05 11:32:32 2011
I am waiting most anxiously to be bamboozled by your most brilliant arguments. Please stop pretending that this site is about Christian ethos or any such bullshit, Vic. It is about shouting into the wind a few opinions no one except a few oddballs like me want to hear. It is all right, Vic, you can scream about archbishops, liberal media, Muslims, and anyone else you care to insult.
By the way, I am submitting a new abbreviation to be added to the choice ones you have.
EWHRN: Egomaniac warmongering homophobic rightwing nutjob.
Waiting for your crude rejoinders,
Date: Wed Apr 06 06:30:44 2011
From: Vic Biorseth
No, I am not tongue tied. I know it’s hard for you to understand, from the viewpoint of your tiny little e-world, but some of us actually have a life outside the internet, and other things to do. This website is not my job; it is a spare time hobby.
I take your EWHRN invention to mean that you might be a let-us-all-roll-over-and-be-conquered-peacenik, a heterophobic sodomite, and a Left-wing Marxist useful idiot, since you so obviously despise the opposites of those things.
This is beginning to get tiresome, and you are skating on the edge here. Either tone it down and go back to rationality or don’t expect to see any more of your submissions published here.
Monday, February 18, 2013
Converted Page to SBI! Release 3.0 BB 2.0.
Date: Thu Sep 25 2014
From: Vic Biorseth
Changes pursuant to changing the website URL
and name from
Thinking Catholic Strategic Center to
Catholic American Thinker.
Pulled the trigger on the 301 MOVE IT option June 1, 2014. Working my way through all the webpages. .
If you want to build a website like this one, this is how you do it.
Never be lukewarm.
Life itself demands passion.
He who is indifferent to God has already forfeited his soul.
He who is indifferent to politics has already forfeited his liberty.
In America, religion is not mere window dressing and citizenship is not a spectator sport.
Do not allow our common destiny as a whole people to just happen without your input.
Seek the Truth; find the Way; live the Life; please God, and live forever.
Catholic American Thinker
Free E-zine Subscription
You will receive immediate email newsletters with links to new articles as they are published here. Your email is perfectly secure here; we use it only to send you the
Catholic American Thinker
and absolutely nothing else.
The Purpose of this grouping of links is to provide a record of Mainstream Media lies, liars and how journalists are trained and paid by their employers to lie.
The Mainstream Media Pages
Day after day, week after week, month after month, year after year, every big name news anchor and reporter in American journalism lied, big, bold and proud, in full support of the Communist cause against America, all throughout the entire Vietnam War, and it has only gotten worse since then.
The Mainstream Media Pages: Soft Marxist Propaganda disguised as News. The Mainstream Media Pages show the linkage between Journalism, Politics and Marxism.
World War III is beginning, and the Big News is the "News"? The world is tumbling into global war, but Journalism is all atwitter about Brian Williams. Go figure.
The field of Journalism is infested with Professional Liars. Professional Liars predominate in the loftier positions of mainstream media.
How Cronkite and the SLIMC lost the Vietnam War for America. With the whole SLIMC overwhelmingly Marxist, the Reds couldn't possibly lose politically and publicly that which they couldn't possibly win militarily in the Vietnam war.
Old Traitors Never Die; They Don't Even Fade Away . . . Cronkite returns, to compare the new Iraq situation to his personal greatest achievement: the loss of the Vietnam War. Perhaps it's wishful thinking on his part.
Regarding the SLIMC Vs. the Truth Regarding the SLIMC (Secularist Liberal Intellectual Media Complex) and its treatment of the Truth
A closer look at the "Bush lied people died" Leftie flagrant categorical lie. If it is true that "Bush Lied, people died" then how does it follow that the UN, and all those countries, and all those Democrats, all said what Bush said, long before he ever said it?
Mainstream Media Lies and Liars just keep foaming up and building pressure. If you want to look at some really fascinating current socio-political phenomena, look at the current build-up of mainstream media lies and liars.
Right and Wrong, and what happens when we no longer recognize it. The difference between Right and Wrong is fixed forever; or, is it?
The Leftie-Liberal Beat Goes On: More anti-American lies reported as "News". The Democratic Party's yellow-bellied cut-and-runners would have you believe that United States Marines are wanton murderers of civilians.
Tet Lie Redux? "Cloning" the massive media lie about Vietnam's Tet Offensive. Tet Lie Redux: An epic, lopsided, monumental military victory was turned into a political defeat by our media's flagrant lies during the Vietnam War. Now, they're doing it again, this time in Iraq.
"The History Channel" repeats the flagrant categorical lies regarding Pius XII. Ho hum, heavy sigh, and here we go again. Once again, we see show-biz "Historians" bypassing actual historical documents in favor of purely anti-Catholic show-biz fictional works, for fun and profit.
What is, and why, this linkage between Fox News and the Playboy Empire? Should prominent men in the public eye work to strengthen our common Western moral ethos, or promote the new and more random, directionless, relativistic moral standard?
Of Illegal Aliens Vs the Berlin Wall, and Sovereignty Vs the Global Village. Marxism - or, if you will, Social Darwinism - presents the notion of Social Evolution, and predicts a final end of national sovereignty, & a perfect, government-less, Global Village; Heaven on Earth.
The greatest tool of the Leftist MSM is the tightly-controlled "opinion poll." Leftist "Spin" is glaringly obvious in mainstream news reporting today. But that Spin is greatly magnified and enhanced through the use of the carefully crafted public opinion poll.
On Evil and Nonsense: Look closely at Nonsense, and find Evil at its root. Evil and Nonsense: deny evil and you deny right vs. wrong; which is to deny common sense, which is to invoke nonsense.
Three Fatal Oversights of the Top Conservative Cognizanti: Glenn, Rush and Sean. Beck, Limbaugh and Hannity are on the right track, but just nibbling around the edges of who the enemy is.
"We belong to the Church militant; and She is militant because on earth the powers of darkness are ever restless to encompass Her destruction. Not only in the far-off centuries of the early Church, but down through the ages and in this our day, the enemies of God and Christian civilization make bold to attack the Creator’s supreme dominion and sacrosanct human rights.”--Pope Pius XII
"It is not lawful to take the things of others to give to the poor. It is a sin worthy of punishment, not an act deserving a reward, to give away what belongs to others."--St. Francis of Assisi
Truth is incontrovertible. Malice may attack it, ignorance may deride it, but in the end, there it is.—Winston Churchill
The smallest minority on earth is the individual. Those who deny individual rights cannot claim to be defenders of minorities.—Ayn Rand
If you can't find the page you're looking for, try the