On Replacing America:  Do detractors really seek replacement, or destruction?

Replacing America or destroying America – what do Democrats and other Marxists really want to do to America?

Vic Biorseth, Thursday, July 14, 2011

Replacing America, or eliminating America – what are the real intentions of America’s Democrat Party and other Marxist-leaning people who are always so antagonistic to her Declaration, her Constitution and her representative government?

All my life I’ve been hearing critics and detractors running America down, emphasizing her worst points, glossing over her finer points, re-interpreting her history in the most negative light, pretending her founders were actually evil, claiming she was being run by “the Jews” or “the Bourgeois” or “the Families” or some secret cabal or other evil entity.

If the intent is to replace the American system with something else, then, what is it to be replaced with?

That should be a very easy thing to describe, for those who intend to “improve” America. Nothing to it; just describe it. Go ahead. Let me see you do it.

America is already described, in beautiful detail, in her founding and constituting documents. America’s very Purpose For Being is beautifully described in the American Declaration of Independence. Exactly how America is constituted and governed is described in detail in the American Constitution. The Constitution is a very simple and straight-forward legal document, written in English, that says very specific legal things. You don’t need any law degree to be able to read and understand it.

So, we – meaning, we America-loving Constitutionalists – have our description of what we love, support, seek to improve and reinforce, primarily in these two brief, simple and straight-forward documents. They are small enough that a copy of both of them fits nicely in my shirt pocket, with lots of room left for a cell phone, a small pad of paper and a pen. Nothing to it. Easy to read, easy to defend.

So, where, pray tell, is the description of what America’s detractors would like to replace all that with? It seems to me that every time I ask one of them to describe it, they are flummoxed. They launch into another anti-American tirade, and have to be brought back to the point again, and again. They cannot describe what they would replace the American system with. They just know – they have been taught – that the American system is bad.

But, you see, they cannot come up with a replacement system. They are incapable of exercising Critical Thinking, because they have never been taught what that is, let alone how to apply it. They have been “educated” in what to think, rather than in how to think.

All of this proves that the typical anti-American is really little more than a simpleton, pretty much incapable of coming up with an original idea of any kind.

The really stupid ones will promote Marx’s invention, which is, of course Communist Utopia. The fact that Communism, as Marx described it, does not exist, has never existed, will never exist, and is quite impossible, is lost on them.

And, of course, there are the real idiots – the anarchists. All they “know” – or think they know – is that the system, like all systems, is bad, and must be destroyed. It’s what they were taught in school. Embedded in “public” education is the effort, invented by Eric Fromm and Abraham Maslow, to develop the new man known as the anti-authority Revolutionary. Here is their glowing description of this New Man:

”The revolutionary is the man who has emancipated himself from ties of blood and soil, from his mother and his father, from special loyalties to state, class, race, party, or religion.”

That, my dear reader, is a description of an unhappy and unstable sociopath. I liken it to an isotope. An unbalanced atom is an unhappy atom – it will do something. Like an isotope, a sociopath will not merely stand there forever. Sooner or later, he will do something.

Now, this revolutionary “philosophy” born of the likes of Fromm and Maslow, and other Darwin-Freud-Marx – inspired anti-Americans such as John Dewey, is deeply imbedded in what is taught in teaching universities, most particularly Columbia University, where the educational elites would have us know that the best of the best public school teachers are taught how to teach. Public – i.e., government – education is, in reality, anti-American political indoctrination.

All those unthinking imbeciles you see walking around wearing Che Guevara T-shirts would love to see “The System” come crashing down, but they don’t have the foggiest clue as to what will come after that. They are not smart enough to even give it a thought.

If you truly hate America, give us an idea as to what might be a good replacement for her. I know it’s hard, and it requires thinking, but try. Give it a good, hard think, and let us know what you can come up with.

Otherwise, just shut the hell up.


Reference Material

Return to Web Site Log (BLOG) page

Return to HOME PAGE

Hover-Link Footnotes:  For the convenience of those readers using devices that lack a mouse, these footnotes are provided for all webpages, in case any webpage contains any hover-links.  (If you don't have a mouse, you can't "hover" over a link.)

SLIMC1 Secularist Liberal Intellectual Media Complex
GESGOEAEOT2 Gradually, Ever So Gradually, Over Eons And Eons Of Time
PEWAG3 Punctuated Equilibrium's Wild Assed Guess
TTRSTF4 Them There Real Scientifical Type Fellers
TTRSPTF5 Them There Real Smart Perfesser Type Fellers
TTRSJTF6 Them There Real Smart Journalistical Type Fellers
SNRTACBT7 Surely No Right Thinking Adult Could Believe Today
STNSEACPB8 Surely Today No Serious, Educated Adult Could Possibly Believe
WDN9 We Don't Know
BMDFP10 Baboons, Mongrel Dogs, Filthy Pigs
HBAACOTE11 Human Beings Are A Cancer On The Earth
ACLU12 Anti-Christian Litigation Union
FLORMPORIF13 Flagrant Liar, Or, Mindless Parrot, Or, Innocent Fool
MEJTML14 Marxist Ends-Justify-The-Means Liar
IEJTML15 Islamic Ends-Justify-The-Means Liar
MPAV16 Marxist Principles And Values
WBESSWG17 Wise, Benign, Elite, Super-Scientific World Governance
TRMITM18 The Reason Man's In This Mess


Web-Page Comments, Dialogues, Latest Updates

Date: Sun Jul 17 19:11:26 2011
From: Karl
Location: Toronto

Why did you stop the argument on your facebook page? It was just getting good and suddenly it disappeared. What are you afraid of?

I have looked at your site contents, and you seem to oppose scientific reality at every point. You deny the scientific theory of life, and you have your own theory on the beginning point of human life, in opposition to all scientists on the subject.

Do you even know what the term anal-retentive means? You should look it up; it applies to you.

Date: Mon Jul 18 06:06:50 2011
From: Vic Biorseth


While I do love a good argument, it is never profitable to argue with a fool. The guy on FaceBook did what all unprepared, provably wrong and yet obstinate people do in that situation: he turned to vulgarity and the ad hominem attack on the messenger rather than the message. I argue points of contention; I do not merely stand around and swap insults. When I blocked him, I didn’t know that blocking him would remove all the previous things he said; but that’s what happens in FaceBook, and whenever a conversation descends to that level, blocking the person is what I will resort to. I won’t have that kind of garbage on my own FaceBook wall.

Again, I fear nothing. I stand in the center of the open field with my rhetorical sword drawn. If you want to continue the argument, just step out here.

To what scientific theory of life do you refer? The beginning point of life? Show me the observations, the duplicable empirical evidence and the peer-reviewed independently verified experiments.

Regarding the beginning point of human life, what did the DNA say that the living sperm cell was? What did the DNA say that the living egg cell was? What did the DNA of the living Zygote cell say that it was? Human life does not begin, it is transmitted; it continues, until an event called extinction. What do you think is developing in the uterus of a pregnant woman? It’s not a particularly good place to grow potatoes, is it? What do you suppose it could possibly be if it is not alive and it is not human? Of course, if it was not alive, or if it was not human, then it would not be a human pregnancy, would it?

Regarding Freud’s theoretical five stages of development, including the anal retentive stage, like the rest of Freud’s half-baked theories, is just a lot of crap, like everything else in Freudianism. It sounds good, and it seems to answer a lot of questions.

If someone asks for your astrological sign and you lie and say that you are a Capricorn, an expected response may be “I knew it!” because, for many who follow astrology, everything makes sense only when put into astrological terms. They will force-fit you into the category that astrology says you belong in.

In a similar manner, many students read Freud’s stages of development for the first time, and suddenly, to them, everything makes sense, and they begin putting everyone they know into Freud’s little boxes, just as the fans of astrology put everyone into astrological boxes, because, suddenly, “it makes everything so clear!” to them.

But there is nothing to back it up other than Freud’s purely subjective “observations” of people – not from infancy, just from pure subjective theory. Never tested, never backed up by anything, and most certainly, not scientific by any stretch of the imagination.

You should look up the scientific method some time; you might be surprised at how often it was not used by the founders of great, recognized scientific theories.



Monday, March 04, 2013
Converted Page to SBI! Release 3.0 BB 2.0. 

Note, March 04, 2013:

To those looking for FaceBook contact - I now avoid FaceBook almost at all costs. Having had my account hacked, my FaceBook ID hijacked, insults and vulgarities published, in my name and with my profile picture, on my wall and on friend's walls, and having received no help, support or even human contact with FaceBook, I no longer participate in what I consider to be dangerous FaceBook communications.

I apologize for not "friending" the many requests that come in. It started out with not wanting to "friend" anyone who's personal profile self-description information was limited to non-existent, because I do not choose to friend enemies of God or America. Finally, it wound up not trusting anyone who wants to be friends, because enemies of God and/or America are, after all, liars with ulterior motives that are not good.

All I do on FaceBook any more is post links to new articles as they are published on this site. I can do that from here. 

Here, on this site, I have a lot more control. No one hacks into this site.

And, I just never did like Twitter.

Sorry, but that's the way it is.



Date:   Mon Sep 29 2014
From:  Vic Biorseth

Changes pursuant to changing the website URL and name from 
Thinking Catholic Strategic Center to
Catholic American Thinker.

Pulled the trigger on the 301 MOVE IT option June 1, 2014. Working my way through all the webpages.  . 



Please note the language and tone of this monitored Website. This is not the place to stack up vulgar one-liners and crude rejoinders.  While you may support, oppose or introduce any position or argument, submissions must meet our standards of logical rigor and civil discourse.  We will not participate in merely trading insults, nor will we tolerate participants merely trading insults.  Participants should not be thin-skinned or over sensitive to criticism, but should be prepared to defend their arguments when challenged.  If you don’t really have a coherent argument or counter-argument of your own, sit down and don’t embarrass yourself. Nonsensical, immoral or merely insulting submissions will not be published here.  If you have something serious to contribute to the conversation, back it up,  keep it clean and keep it civil.  We humbly apologize to all religious conservative thinkers for the need to even say these things, but the New Liberals are what they are, and the internet is what it is. 

If you fear repercussions, do not use your real name and
do not include email or any identifying information. 


Please note that all fields followed by an asterisk must be filled in.

Please enter the word that you see below.


Copyrighted Material

Your ad here
Looking for Limited Constitutional Government?  Fiscal Responsibility? Free Markets? Welcome Home!

Get in there! Get connected! For God's sake, DO SOMETHING!

Give me Liberty or give me death, Hell!  Give me Liberty, or I'll get up and take it.  Click here for contemporary American political positions.
About Your Host

Never be lukewarm.
Life itself demands passion.
He who is indifferent to God has already forfeited his soul.
He who is indifferent to politics has already forfeited his liberty.
In America, religion is not mere window dressing and citizenship is not a spectator sport.
Do not allow our common destiny as a whole people to just happen without your input.

Welcome to my website.

Catholic American Thinker Free E-zine Subscription

Enter Your E-mail Address
Enter Your First Name (optional)

Don't worry — your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you Catholic American Thinker.

Catholic American Thinker Back Issues

Keep This Website Going

Do you Know something?
Does it need to be said?

Write It.

Related WebPages

The Purpose for this grouping of links is to highlight the three natural divisions, in philosophy, religion, morality and politics; what is proper, what is disengaged and what must be defeated.

The Winnowing Pages
Ben Franklin described the division of the time as the Loyalists, the Rebels and the Mug-Whumps, with their Mugs hanging over one side of the fence, and their Whumps hanging over the other.  Today, we have the Constitutionalists, the anti-Constitutionalists, and the Moron Vote. 

The Three Sociological Divisions: The Faithful; The Disengaged; The Faithless. Those who stand in Truth, those who oppose Truth, and those who are Lukewarm toward Truth comprise the Three Sociological Divisions.

There is a time appointed for everything; this is the time of winnowing. We must politically winnow, to separate into good grain, useful straw, and useless flammable chaff.

Against political moderation: America was not founded by indecisive moral wimps. Political Moderation provides neither leadership nor opposition, but merely a moral drag that historically prolongs moral debates and ends up hurting morality.

Blessed Polarization & Political Division: what America desperately needs today. Lord, give us blessed polarization, a line drawn in the sand and a polarizing leader like Sarah Palin to lead us back to American sanity.

America’s return to faith in God is now a matter of American national survival. If America does not return to faith in God, no return to “conservatism” will save her; it will only prolong her death agony.

Faith versus Atheism: Is atheism really just a silly superstition? The Faith versus Atheism argument is at the root of every other important argument.

Constitutional America: The argument for a return to basic rule of law. The arguments for a return to the Constitutional America intended by the Fathers and expected by the People through their Representative Government.

Atheizing America - we sit, seemingly mesmerized, merely watching it happen. Among all Leftist agendas, the atheizing America agenda is the one we seem to notice the least. Like deer in the headlights, we just stand there and watch.

A fatal false premise is a deadly logical trap for the mal-educated person. A Fatal false premise with broad general consensus will always trump reason, evidence and critical thinking.

The World says: Faith Versus Reason. The Spirit says: Faith And Reason. Choose. Is it possible to be a man of faith and reason simultaneously? Or is true faith exclusively reserved for dumb hillbillies, bible-thumping zealots, and unthinking cradle traditionalists?

Behold the Masters of Hypocrisy who denigrate us and highlight their own shame. Good Leadership, for the Masters of Hypocrisy, means Surrender to the World and Follow The Mob.

Of all the dumb-assed ideas in the world, the dumbest is The Equality Stupidity. The Equality Stupidity takes the prize for the most imbecilic of all ideologies.

On Replacing America: Do detractors seek replacement, or destruction? Replacing America, or destroying America - what do Democrats and other fundamental Marxists want to do to America?

Even the very best among us can be fooled into blessing abomination. In blessing abomination we show how we have been mesmerized by the slyest of lies.

Old North Dayton
is looking for
A Few Good Men
who are Catholic Priests, retired, about to retire or available for reasignment.
You are a priest forever, of the Order of Melchizedek.
They dedicated their whole lives to the Lord, and to the uplifting of man. Think of where the world would be if not for them. Support them all you can.
Traditional Latin Tridentine Mass, offered at Assumption Grotto Church in  Detroit, Michigan.  Our deepest prayer, our highest form of worship, and the way God should be treated.  Click here for Latin Mass availability nearest to you, and to add your Latin Mass Church to the list.
Note the Military Assault Rifle common to the American Founding Era.
Your ad here

Atheist Genesis:

In the beginning there was nothing, and nothing happened to nothing.
And then nothing accidentally exploded and created everything.
And then some bits of everything accidentally encountered other bits of everything and formed some new kinds of everything.
And then some bits of everything accidentally arranged themselves into self-replicating bits of everything.
And then some self-replicating bits of everything accidentally arranged themselves into dinosaurs.

(See The Darwinism Pages)

Torn and tattered, bruised and battered, but still flying high.

General Commentary Pages
Various unrelated topics that stirred thought and provoked writing (or quoting) at one time or another. The Everything Else Bucket.

Undoing Evil: Unraveling the sly "Good Intentions" destroying the West. Undoing Evil means reversing Political Correctness and Amorality, and returning to Pure Meritocricy.

Letter to an American Warrior, from an old American Citizen, with Love. An old man's advice to a young man, sent in a letter to an American Warrior.

The Judas Complex: How a traitor may not recognized his own treason. The Judas Complex explains how Judas Iscariot - like many a modern day Bishop - compromised with the world.

Christmas 2014:  Hope is Reborn; Salvation has come into the world. The Christmas 2014 Turning Point:  The Kingdom is upon us; our King is among us.

A Personal Relationship with Jesus Christ deepens faith and faith commitment.  A Personal Relationship with America deepens love of country and patriotic commitment.

Work at home jobs that have had me. A long, costly and unsuccessful run at work from home jobs that didn't work for us.

Truth versus Agenda addresses the simplest of problems greatly complexified. Truth versus Agenda examines the contest between reality and its opposition.

Vic has Iron Weights for sale; Mama says they have to go. Lots of iron weights for sale; all have to go at once, in one sale.

My poor old truck is again starting to look like a poor old truck. After half-a-million miles, we're now approaching another decision time; another paint job, or a new truck.

A Palin Parker Ticket? My Dream Candidates for 2012. Why a Palin Parker ticket is better than any professional politician Republican ticket you can come up with for 2012.

Elitism Vs Palinism: Why the Left and the Elites Loath and Fear Sarah Palin. It isn’t just Marxism Vs Palinism; it’s also established intellectual elitism vs Palinism. The elite need someone to look down upon.

Here we see Bush family class captured in a simple private citizen’s photo. George W. (and Mrs.) Bush quietly demonstrate Bush family class without hoopla or fanfare.

Marxists love crisis, and they love an oil spill crisis most of all. Marxists even create and drive crisis. Their favorite crisis of all must be the Oil Spill Crisis, which is even better than a Banking Crisis.

The Godless Left leads the young and naive to their utopian Hell. For an honest comparison of the effects on youth, we need to look to the history of the Godless Left versus the Religious Right.

On Threats to America's National Existence. A look at the nature of our national existence, what makes us America, physical threats to that, and the possibility of just going out of existence.

On the ethics of language: English dictionary Vs. Political-Correctness taboos. Language evolves, yet morals are (or should be) fixed. This poses questions re the ethics of language.

Thinking Catholic direction: threats to America, Church, Ethos, even History. The Thinking Catholic Direction is multi-faceted, facing threats to American National Existence, Catholic Liturgy, our common Guiding Ethos - emphasis changes to meet the threat of the moment.

The website is going on hold for at least the next five weeks. Business calls, and I must respond. Will be traveling, and not taking the laptop this time.

Current Website Status. Still too busy for individual responses to questions, comments & criticisms.

Our 2006 Ohio Voter Guide. The choices are quite clear, and the 2006 Ohio Voter Guide was easy to produce.

On carrying my Lord, Jesus Christ, in my pocket. As a Eucharistic Minister, I am on occasion carrying the Lord Jesus in my pocket. It's a wondrous thing.

A 2006 Christmas and Hanukkah wish. May the Holy Days we celebrate remind us all of who we are, and how we are different from other peoples.

Current Democratic Party platform reveals anti-Semitic streak among Liberals. In their voting, their speechifying, and in the slant of their controlled mainstream media reporting, the current Democratic Party Platform is made clear to all observers.

The "Left", and The DaVinci Code, The Passion, and Cartoons of Mohammed. You can tell a lot about a movement by its public words.  The Passion? "Unreservedly Bad." The DaVinci Code? "Unreservedly Good." Anything to do with Islam? "No Comment."

Home For Christmas 2008. Website Getting Active Again

Hydrogen power could be, and should be, the wave of our automotive future. Any move toward hydrogen power is a move toward a cleaner and more efficient fuel, and away from our dangerous dependency on oil.

Kerry lies again, and then lies about his lies, in concert with the SLIMC. There he goes again! Kerry lies again and again about American servicemen and veterans; he just can't help himself.

What's going on with Mel Gibson? Is he really an anti-Semite? I am surprised that Mel Gibson is an alcolholic.  But I am never surprised at any words that come out of the mouth of any drunk.

Still Worrying Over NuVo Consequences. The Holidays have gone by, several days have passed, and the SANE  NuVo Initiative still stands pat.

The Dem's October Surprise involves another flip-flop of their public "standard". The clearly pro-sodomy Party that openly seeks the "Gay" vote goes Victorian for another pre-election October Surprise ploy.

Some Problems with NuVo: the so-called Null-Vote Initiative. A "philosophical" movement aimed at keeping religious conservatives from voting? Seriously? Let me state my problems with NuVo.

Come, let us sit and reason together. Jews and Christians of various stripe and spot can say to each other, 'Come, let us sit and reason together.' But we can't do that with the Moslems.

Regarding SANE works dropping NuVo: Nul Vote Initiative dies with a whimper. If you can't really present a good argument, sit down. On SANE Works dropping the NuVo Initiative: a program that works hard to SOUND pro-American while ACTING to oppose American National Existence.

Even experts grossly underestimate the Marxist zeal of the American Left. The sharp Left turn happened in the Hoover-FDR era, and the Marxism of the American Left has been deepening ever since.

Thinking American, in a nutshell: When one has lots to say, but time is limited. The older I get, the busier I get. Answering multiple questions as a thinking American, but in a hurry.

"We are an Easter People, and Hallelujah is our Song." (John Paul the Great) Our absolutely unique and singular Easter story, and the incredible force with which it struck human history.

Witnessing, grieving and weeping for our dieing culture.  What might it take to call a whole people back from the brink of cultural death?

So how come we have all these homeless people if our system is so great? The strong "Utopian Idealist" firmly believes that absolute worldly perfection is actually possible.  Therefore, there should never be any such thing as a hungry or homeless person.

Taking a look at Illegal Imigration and Tax Problem solutions. In our view, the minimum wage and income tax have outlived their usefulness, and only contribute to the illegal alien problem. 

First journal / blog entries when the thinking catholic blog first opened up. Notes to readers about what I was doing. 

On-going WebSite work and planned WebPages as of 09/07/2006. Adding items to book store. 

Vic's busted finger status - life goes on. Another busted finger status report, since the original one rolled off of the 50-entry BLOG update records.

Website Status as of 02/05/2009. No more Bookstore; no more Contact Me; no more complexity.

Website Status 03-09-2009. Just a note to bring you up to date on website status 03-09-2009.

Website Status 04/06/2009. Busy driving daily now; most website work will be weekend and as available.

The Plastic Bags and Eco Doom theory: will plastic bags end life as we know it? Plastic Bag and Eco Doom predictions tell us that plastic grocery and garbage bags will still be buried in the land fills and dumps a thousand years from now.  Well … so what?

Farewell Smokey Biorseth; Rest In Peace.  Hello Coal Biorseth; Welcome Home. As we were laying our beloved Smokey Biorseth to rest in his grave beside the lilies, a carbon-copy of Smokey, in younger form, emerged from the lilies.

Honky Biorseth really runs this house. If you want to know what's in any cabinet in the house, just ask Honky Biorseth.

More Marxist infiltration of higher education. Public school and the media are not the only places dominated by Marxist thought; even Catholic institutions are infected.

Of Families and Fortunes, and Inheritance Vs. Redistribution. Families and Fortunes are despised by Marxists, because Marxism demonizes the family, demonizes fortunes, and even demonizes profit.

Website Status Update 11/09/10. Just a Website status update; where we are and where we’re going.

Regarding the 2010 Tax Deal Pledge Breaker: Pledge? What Pledge? How can Republican deal makers even face us? We need to hang a Tea Party target on all professional politicians for 2012.

Pray for peace in Jerusalem, and for deliverance of Israel from harm. To pray for peace in Jerusalem is to pray for deliverance from Obama.

A tale of Promised Financial Melt-Down Debt Ceiling Nonsense and Happy Marxists. Everyone, on both sides, believes the Debt Ceiling Nonsense.  Why?

Our Ohio voter Guide for the 2012 Election. The 2l012 Ohio Voter Guide – The Choices Have Never Been Clearer, or more critical.

Evangelization enters the animal kingdom with the first bear prayer. It is fitting that the first bear prayer would be a prayer of thanksgiving.

Is the Internet down in Lithuania? Sudden loss of Lithanian traffic suggests the internet is down in Lithuania. 

The rise of the Femi Nazi Green Beret, and the decline of military victory. The first Femi Nazi Green Beret will be awarded out of fairness, not excellence.

Food Insurance: Is this stuff really any good? All of us conspiracy-theorizing, global-calamity doomsday-preppers need their Food Insurance.

We just had to try to do Robert Irvine's Plastic Wrapped Baby Back Ribs. Put plastic wrapped baby back ribs in the oven? What? Are you nuts?

Thoughts on the first Eucharist, established by the Last Supper.  The first Eucharist was recognized by the Apostles for what it was on that holiest Holy Thursday.

Tea-Party-Candidates-04-18-2014.  The Constitution is not going to be restored to legal preeminence unless we replace leadership incumbents of BOTH PARTIES.

Ecce homo; Behold the man.  Ecce Homo.  Behold the Innocent Lamb, who takes away the sins of the world.

When your system slows down or hangs, it's time for a Total System Reboot.  America, the World, and even the Catholic Church may need a Total System Reboot.

Looking for Limited Constitutional Government?  Fiscal Responsibility? Free Markets? Welcome Home!

Get in there! Get connected! For God's sake, DO SOMETHING!

Give me Liberty or give me death, Hell!  Give me Liberty, or I'll get up and take it.  Click here for contemporary American political positions.

If you can't find the page you're looking for, try the