Formerly the Thinking Catholic Strategic Center
Vic Biorseth, Tuesday, May
Here are the words that gave birth to Organized Labor:
Those are the words of Karl Marx. They are a pure incitement to violent revolution. "Proletarians" means "Workers". The "Ruling Classes" means the employers, or, the demonized "Bourgeois".
Your local baker or butcher is a "Petty Bourgeois", and so are you, if you are just a middle-class employee who has not yet joined a union or joined the revolution in some other capacity.
The whole revolutionary idea behind Communism is to put the workers in charge of the workplace; to take the "Capital" owned by the Bourgeois and put it into the hands of the Proletariat. Then the workers would own the factories and farms and everything, and they would pay themselves, and maybe periodically go on strike against themselves for more pay, or grievances, or whatever.
The original business owners would theoretically be dead.
Note that the goal is global. Read the words again. All workers would own everything everywhere, and, one would suppose, they would know everything they would need to know to make it all work.
And if you think all that is workable, you're as dumb as Bernie Sanders.
Real Marxists know that the true goal is not Communism's vaunted Worker's Paradise at all, but Dictatorship. Many union members are completely oblivious to all of this, but not all of them. Many more are what Marxism refers to as their "Useful Idiots" who ignorantly help the process toward what they believe will be a better society, but what in reality will be a future of brutal violence and tyranny.
The violent revolution part of it hasn't worked in America, at least not yet; but that doesn't mean the long term goals of Marxism haven't been advanced by it. Union leadership draws anti-social types to it like manure draws flies. Union leaders have historically been common criminals and big time gangsters, whether publicly espousing Marxism or not; Marxism and crime just go together.
We have addressed this previously, among the Unionism Pages and elsewhere. My real problem with modern, Marxified organized labor is not so much the notions of solidarity and close comradeship of workers as it is the establishment of unnecessary animosity between employee and employer, when both should be working for the success of the enterprise, in the better interest of both. Unions always work to destroy the natural bond between employer and employee, and make them into enemies of each other. When they should be friends.
Organized labor unions promote the myth of Robin Hood, in the romanticized version of Wealth Redistribution. They take from the bourgeois business owners for the benefit of their members, making the rank and file happy, because they receive more than the fair market price for their labor. The cost of labor is no longer set by the natural laws of supply and demand, but by the threat of the organized strike, which may be against whole industries, or even against whole nations. The union bosses, living off of Union Dues, pass on some percentage of union dues on to the Marxocrat Party and the most pro-Marxist, pro-Crime politicians, in exchange for pro-labor, anti-American government action.
The Marxocrat Party loves Organized Labor; Organized Labor loves the Marxocrat Party. Both abhor honest work for fair pay, and both promote the myth that real honest work for fair pay is quite impossible without unions, because Capitalism is a "system of greed".
What the rank and file union man seldom recognizes is the destructive effect all of this has on the business that pays his wages. It forces businesses to cut labor, seek automation, move somewhere else, or go out of business altogether. They don't see the falsehood behind the myth of the unlimited wealth of the businessman. But, you see, businessmen go into business to earn a living for themselves and their families; nobody goes into business because he's rich. When a businessman cannot make a living at his business, he shuts his business down and does something else for a living.
That's the way it is.
As it is for the small business, so it is for the large corporate business; all large businesses started out as small ones, but even after incorporating, even after being sold and resold, merged and re-merged, even after humongous growth, the purpose of the business remains the same: to make a profit for the owners. When it cannot do that, it will move, or it will go out of business and shut down.
Very simple; nothing to it; but seldom understood by the rank and file.
When natural laws are violated the unpredictable results are never good.
Like the Welfare Queen, and like the criminal alien Etitetelista, the Union Man has been conditioned and trained and indoctrinated into seeing his high wages as an entitlement, and a right, that is just due to him by mere dint of the fact that he exists. He always paid his dues, so he has that money coming to him, regardless of the condition of the employer, or the industry, or the nation, or the world. His wages come first, ahead of everything. They are his due.
On top of all of this opposition to allowing the free market to set the price of labor, as it does (or should do) for prices and availability of raw materials and finished goods and services, we have unnatural Child Labor laws, and Minimum Wage laws, and Graduated Income tax laws, and piles and piles of OSHA and other unconstitutional, unlegislated, unrepresentative workplace regulations harming business in America.
Our child labor laws were based more on Dickens-type novels on the "horrors" (never the positives) of the Industrial Revolution than on practical reality. There is nothing wrong with children working while still children. Child labor laws stunt development of good workers and the development of useful skills while still a child.
If today's child labor laws had been in effect back then,
and many more examples could be cited. Once upon a time children were "apprenticed-out" to various craftsmen and professionals to learn a trade or a profession, at very young ages. And, all children worked at home, doing all the chores necessary for the upkeep of home and garden and chickens, the milk cow and whatever else the family typically had, even in towns. Farm children did everything necessary for the business of the farm, from the earliest ages they were able, and by the time they were grown they were very experienced farmers.
In those days, every grown adult knew full well how to make a living. They were already doing it. Confidently.
Compare that to today, and tell me how child labor laws are good.
Child abuse and child labor are two very different things. If a child is seeking a job, he should be perfectly free to find one. No one should ever be free to abuse a child.
Minimum wage laws are another unnatural interference with the natural laws of supply and demand. Heartwarming good intentions aside, all they do, along with child labor laws, is to eliminate a lot of available work, or, drive it underground, in a black-market of illegal labor.
The Church complicates the matter with promoted "fair wage" theology. For example, there is this:
That looks good on paper, but in all practicality, it simply doesn't always work for every available work opportunity. Taken literally, it would eliminate all part-time, multiple job opportunities, and it would eliminate entry-level or training jobs.
"Remuneration for work should guarantee man the opportunity to provide a dignified livelihood for himself and his family on the material, social, cultural and spiritual level" is the part most Catholics take too literally, and,
"taking into account the role
and the productivity of each, the state of the business, and the common
good." is the part most Catholics never read, or ignore, or do not recognize.
How does that apply to the neighbor kid who mows your lawn?
I know, I know, paragraph 2434 is not supposed to be taken literally and applied to every single job on earth. But it is taken literally, and it is applied to every single job on earth, by otherwise good fellow Catholics who have been Marxified. It may be the most quoted paragraph in discussions on Social Justice.
First of all, all employers are not Catholic. Paragraph 2434 puts Catholic employers at a distinct business disadvantage against competing non-Catholic free-market employers. Loss of market share can be total; it can put an otherwise good business out of business.
Paragraph 2434, taken incorrectly, yes, but still taken the way most fellow Catholics with whom I have discussed it take it, would eliminate all jobs having to do with pay by piece-work, all jobs paid by commission, and even hourly work, unless the hours were rigidly fixed. And who gets to decide exactly what amount of remuneration provides a "dignified livelihood" for the worker and his entire household? A Congress? A President? A Dictator?
What does government even have to do with it, unless the worker works for the government?
For me, natural law sorts it out best. All sorts of jobs are available; all sorts of business opportunities are available; all sorts of workers are available; all of them - workers, businessmen, would-be entrepreneurs, employers, corporations, career seekers, career providers, etc. - are all free to seek their own way, by their own free will, for their own best advantage. Kind of like religions. The sweetest success is arrived at voluntarily.
Economic success, at any level, cannot be forced, or engineered, or dictated. Planned and fiercely controlled economics is only a path to mass poverty and eventual economic collapse. It never works; it never ends well.
All citizens have a right to free association with others, including organized labor unions. But it may not be argued that organized labor unions have a right to impose rules on the larger society that is not associated with it. If it is not a constitutional part of the government, then it has no authority to make any rules binding on anyone other than its own members.
A Constitutionalist President and/or a Constitutionalist Congress could and should declare the withholding of union dues from government worker's paychecks to be unconstitutional and end all such deductions and pass-throughs. Government workers would still be free to maintain union membership, but they would have to pay their own union dues out of their own private property full paychecks.
The tax payers owe nothing to the unions. The reason collective bargaining cannot work in government, and should be outlawed wherever it is not already outlawed, is that the government is not paying government worker wages. The taxpayer is the one paying all government worker pay, and the taxpayer is not and cannot be represented at the collective bargaining table.
A Constitutionalist Congress and a Constitutionalist President could and should legislate new law abrogating any existing contractual agreement between unions and private business requiring businesses to withhold union dues from worker's paychecks as a normal part of the business' payroll process, at the business' discretion. Unions should have no authority over any business' payroll process. Employees would still be free to be union members, but they would have to pay their own union dues out of their income. Dues would be a matter between unions and members, and no one else. It would be entirely up to the employer whether he wished to continue deducting and passing on union dues to the unions; if he wished to stop doing it, he could.
A Constitutionalist President and/or a Constitutionalist Congress could and should declare all "Closed Shop" laws or government regulations pertaining to any locality or any business or industry to be unconstitutional, null and void. No citizen should be forced against his will to join a union just to gain employment at a preferred place of employment. And no citizen should be forced against his will to pay dues to any organization he does not chose to support.
My guess is that a significant number of current union members are not too crazy about being union members in the first place. It would be very interesting to see how many of them would like to keep all of their pay in their own pocket instead of paying their union dues.
Sarcastic Acronym Hover-Link Footnotes: For the convenience of those readers using devices that lack a mouse, these footnotes are provided for all webpages, in case any webpage contains any hover-links. (If you don't have a mouse, you can't "hover" it over a link without clicking just to see the simple acronym interpretation. Click any footnote link to see the acronym and a detailed explanation.)SLIMC1 Secularist Liberal Intellectual Media Complex
The Brilliantly Conceived Organization of the USA; Vic Biorseth
Return to the BLOG page
Return to the HOME PAGE
Subscribe to our Free E-Zine News Letter
Respond to This Article Below The Last Comment
Never be lukewarm.
Life itself demands passion.
He who is indifferent to God has already forfeited his soul.
He who is indifferent to politics has already forfeited his liberty.
In America, religion is not mere window dressing and citizenship is not a spectator sport.
Do not allow our common destiny as a whole people to just happen without your input.
Get in the fight! Engage the Enemy!
Seek the Truth; find the Way; live the Life; please God, and live forever.
All Published Articles
By Publication Date
Catholic American Thinker
Free E-zine Subscription
You will receive immediate email newsletters with links to all new articles as they are published here. Your email is perfectly secure here; we use it only to send you the
Catholic American Thinker
and absolutely nothing else.
Enter ye in at the narrow gate: for wide is the gate, and
broad is the way that leadeth to destruction, and many there are who go in
thereat. How narrow is the gate, and strait is the way that leadeth to life:
and few there are that find it! Beware of false prophets, who come to you in
the clothing of sheep, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.
Jesus Christ; Matt 7:13-15
This grouping of links provides a repository for all agenda items necessary to get the American Federal Government back under the American Constitution and performing in strict accordance with it.
Restoring Constitutional America Pages
If it isn't in Article One Section Eight, the federal government shouldn't be doing it. If it violates any part of the Constitution, especially the Bill Of Rights, the federal government shouldn't be doing it.
Breaking the Parties: Ending unconstitutional, illegal control of government. Political Parties were never Constitutional. Making American government more manageable, representative and Constitutional begins with breaking the Parties.
Breaking the Media: ending control and slanting of public political opinion. A return to American Constitutionalism and recognizing truth requires breaking the media's controlling relationship to American politics.
Breaking-Taxation: Ending all taxes on all Private Property, including Income. And if your income is not your private property, then, whose is it? Ending all unrepresentative, regulatory and unconstitutional taxes.
Breaking Regulation: Ending unconstitutional, unlegislated lawmaking. Breaking Regulation means shutting down unrepresentative and unconstitutional bureaucracies that make regulations with full force of law behind them.
Breaking Dissimilation: Cultural Evil masquerading as Assimilation. Breaking Dissimilation means maintaining Who We Are, as a Distinct People, in the face of Forced, Purposeful Immigration of Evil.
Breaking Obamacare: Eliminating Socialized Medicine once and for all. Breaking Obamacare and showing that neither Health Care nor Health Care Insurance are the Constitutional business of the federal government.
Breaking Public Education: Killing Tax-Paid Anti-American Indoctrination. Breaking Public Education at the federal level may be the only way to kill Common Core under all its aliases.
Breaking Anti-Constitution Culture Rot: Making America Good Again. America cannot be great again until she is good again, and becoming good again requires breaking anti-Constitution culture-rot.
Breaking Unions: Ending Marxism's intrusion into work place relationships. Breaking Unions means breaking the very reason Organized Labor was originally Organized: to provide a path to violent revolution.
Breaking Marxism: Excising America's destructive social parasite. Breaking Marxism will be a tougher job than Breaking Islam, because "Cultural Marxism" is now interwoven into our national cultural fabric.
Breaking Islam: Getting Islam out of America, and making war on Jihad. Constitutional survival demands breaking Islam and breaking Marxism in America, and opposing their progress elsewhere in the world.
Breaking Voter Fraud: Ending Alien, Unidentified and Domestic Enemy Voting. The whole goal of open borders, amnesty, opposing voter-ID and early voting is to defraud the system, defeat the Constitution and take over America.
Repairing Defense: Undoing the Obamunist - Marxocrat Party's damage. Repairing Defense is an absolute requirement for American military before any serious military action.
Breaking The UN: De-funding a Globalist, Dependent-Upon-Us Mortal Enemy. The UN is now a Globalist, predominantly Marxist and Moslem, anti-American and anti-sovereignty, corrupt, criminal enterprise. It needs to be broken.
Breaking The FED: Repealing the 1913 Federal Reserve Act to Restore Treasury. Getting America's Currency and Treasure back under America's government requires breaking the FED.
Breaking The Drug Lords: Ending the Drug War by Killing the Black Market. If we are ever to return to being a Constitutional Republic, we must realize that drugs are not covered by the Constitution, and end the Business by killing the Market.
Breaking Globalism: The anti-sovereignty dream of borderless hodgepodge. Globalism: the New Communism. Anti-nation chaos dressed up as Utopia. A phony ideology so stupid it makes my feet hurt.
Breaking Abortion: Rescuing American Civilization from Utter Barbarity. Breaking Abortion is the first step in restoring the Constitution to its rightful place as the Supreme Law of the Land.
Breaking Homo Marriage: What the hell was the Court thinking? Breaking Homo Marriage, as one step among many in getting our three co-equal branches of federal government back into their separate and strictly limited individual Constitutional corners.
Breaking Secularism: Our Unconstitutional "Separation of Church and State". Restoring religious freedom requires breaking secularism, breaking Unconstitutional Political Parties and restoring our original Judaeo-Christian National Ethos.
Breaking Gun Control: Re-establishing Constitutional Citizen Security. Breaking Gun Control means declaring related unconstitutional gun laws to be null and void, because they violate the Second Amendment.
Breaking Chaos: Restoring Order in the face of Evil Revolution. Proactively breaking chaos means re-institutionalizing Truth, through proper fear of the Lord.
Breaking Faux Civil Rights: If it's not Constitutional it's not a Civil Right. If they are not in the Natural Law and not in the Constitution, then they are not "Civil Rights" and they may not be addressed in Federal Law.
Breaking Heterodoxy: Priests can either restore orthodoxy, or they cannot. All the other "Breaking" pages have to do with the Constitution; this one has to do with the return to Roman Catholic Orthodoxy, which leads the way in restoring American cultural morality.
Breaking The Club: Breaking the Big Money control of American Politics. Our Politics are run by money, money, money. Breaking The Establishment Club requires breaking the big money requirement of Professional Politics.
Consequences of Breaking the System and Restoring the Constitution. Assessing the good, bad and ugly consequences of breaking the system of political corruption and returning America to Constitutional Rule.
Could a President Trump destroy the Establishment? You betcha. He could unseat a majority on the Court, unseat much of Congress and virtually destroy the News Media.
The Religion-Political Parallels in America's rise, and in her decline. Boldly speaking about the taboo subjects of religion and politics is what this DIVISIVE and INTERACTIVE website was born to do.
Another Marxist "Catholic Spring"? Yawn. So what else is new? Breaking News: A Catholic Springtime of Revolution. Well, ho hum, heavy sigh and here we go again.
Political Parties = Political Denominationalism = Diversity in Patriotism. Denominationalism varies Revealed Truth; Political Parties vary Constitutional Meaning.
Evil Unmasked: Ryan and the boys openly side with America's enemies. If they won't support their own candidate in a two-person race, which candidate does that leave unopposed?
Invincible Ignorance my ass. It's invincible lawlessness running amuck. Government, academia, journalism and entertainment, all working together as one big criminal enterprise.
The Great Global Deception: "Death of a thousand cuts" applied to Civilization. The Global Deception is Machiavellian-ism applied by inches, in which the "Revolution" never quite comes, because the Target Institution destroys itself.
On the Mythical Conservative Movement of the Republicrat Party. Conservative Movement? What Conservative Movement? There ain't no Conservative Movement.
Stupid Intellectuals: The conservative political sophist circular firing squad. The stupid "intellectuals" in the establishment who just keep shooting themselves.
Defining Rights Down, Reversing Constitutional Meaning and Wrecking America. On Unconstitutional "Hate Speech" and "Hate Crime", established by Flag Burners, America Haters and Constitution Destroyers.
Finding Geographical, Political and Religious True North. It is Knowing True North that properly orients us, and enables us to find the elusive Direction Home.
"We belong to the Church militant; and She is militant because on earth the powers of darkness are ever restless to encompass Her destruction. Not only in the far-off centuries of the early Church, but down through the ages and in this our day, the enemies of God and Christian civilization make bold to attack the Creator’s supreme dominion and sacrosanct human rights.”--Pope Pius XII
"It is not lawful to take the things of others to give to the poor. It is a sin worthy of punishment, not an act deserving a reward, to give away what belongs to others."--St. Francis of Assisi
Truth is incontrovertible. Malice may attack it, ignorance may deride it, but in the end, there it is.—Winston Churchill
The smallest minority on earth is the individual. Those who deny individual rights cannot claim to be defenders of minorities.—Ayn Rand
If you can't find the page you're looking for, try the