Formerly the Thinking Catholic Strategic Center
Vic Biorseth, OWM; Monday,
December 23, 2013
It is hard to accept the fact that a significant portion of the highly educated among the world population, perhaps even a majority, do not hold a correct understanding of simple economics. But here we are. Today, the very term Capitalism itself is most often used as a pejorative, and most people have been educated into viewing it as a "system of greed" rather than as what it actually is.
What prompted this webpage was a plethora of "Please do not publish this" comments from well educated people, clerics among them, in response to the Evangelizing for Communism webpage, in which I criticized Pope Francis' attack on Capitalism and promotion of Socialist redistribution. While most of them agreed with my position, with some exceptions to certain points, none of them - not one - wanted to be "on public record" as critical of the Pope. In fact, they strongly criticized my doing so in public.
(Note that Pope Francis didn't even use the term Unfettered Capitalism in his exhortation, but that just about everyone who commented on it, whether pro or con, did use it.)
The exact same sort of phenomenon occurred after publication of the Pope on Globalism page, in which I was similarly critical of Pope Benedict XVI for his promotion of the idea of a new global government to replace national sovereignty of all nations. Lots of comments, not for publication. They disagreed, not with what I said, but with the fact that I said it out loud. ??? So, we are not even to speak about it in public? Excuse me?
I saw Benedict's words as little more than a recommendation to turn the whole world over to a new WBESSWG17 to properly "take care of us" and be nice. This was, ostensibly, Benedict's solution to the growing world economic crisis.
However, as we showed in the Economic Catastrophe Pages, the growing (and continuing) economic crisis was brought about and caused by government action, not by any free market activity. It was the opposite of Capitalism; it was government interference with the free market that caused the problems, and going to bigger government with more power was not only not the solution, but the sure path to absolute total economic catastrophe. Not to mention the end of liberty.
We will talk about the radical differences between Leo XIII's Rerum Novarum, Benedict XVI's Caritas Veritate and Francis' Evangelii Gaudium in a future webpage, to be titled Social Justice. Here we will only note that Leo XIII's encyclical very strongly condemned the notion of "community property" in favor of the natural law and private property, quoting Deut. 5:21, ""Thou shalt not covet thy neighbour's wife; nor his house, nor his field, nor his man-servant, nor his maid-servant, nor his ox, nor his ass, nor anything that is his."
What are the limits of Papal authority when addressing political, socioeconomic and civil government architectures? I am not sure; this whole area is fuzzy in my mind, and perhaps someone out there can make the picture more clear. We described, in the Judeo-Christian Ethos page, how the first Commandments of God address man's relationship with God, or our faith. And how the following Commandments of God address man's relationship with his fellow man, or our morality. These are the two areas in which Popes and Councils in communion with Popes can speak with absolute authority, under guidance of the Holy Ghost, as we said in the Infallibility page. That does not mean that they always speak with absolute authority in these areas.
But Smith published Wealth of Nations in 1776, and Marx published Communist Manifesto in 1848, both long after the closing of the sacred deposit of faith, upon which Popes and Councils speak infallibly. If it's not in the deposit of faith, it is not something that can be declared as a new doctrine. That's my understanding.
The Scotsman Adam Smith described the free market in his Wealth of Nations, he didn't invent it. It was a natural thing, that came into being by individual men trying to improve their own condition in life. The more they struggled to do that, and the more they were allowed, i.e., not constrained in any way from doing it, they more pennies they could save, which is another way of saying the more wealthy they could become. He showed that it was an accumulation of natural individual citizen actions that ultimately created the wealth of whole nations. Newly created wealth trickles down, one way or another.
Marx was probably the first to use the word Capitalism in his condemnation of the free market in his Das Kapital. What most modern day philosophical Communists do not know is that the whole of his Communist ideology was a purposeful fraud. Under the influence of the deceit and treachery in the writings of Machiavelli, and the cold methodology in the writings of Hegel, he painted a beautiful picture of a path to man-made human perfection to draw in disciples. But the true aim, from the beginning, was, purely, the assumption of political power. We tried to highlight this in Refuting Marx, and in all the other pages among The Marxism Pages.
The true goal of Marxism was and is the assumption of pure dictatorial power, whether by direct Machiavellian treacherous "revolution" by deceived, sacrificial agent provocateurs, or through Hegelian "progressive" steps. All to be done in deceit, under the deceptive mask of the achievement of perfect human equality and an end to poverty and hunger; who would be against that?
No other polemic or manifesto ever deceived so many people over so many decades into becoming willing accomplices in their own slavery. Even after being openly called Useful Idiots by famous dictators such as Lenin and Stalin, new Useful Idiots continue to be recruited to the Marxist cause to this very day.
So what is Unfettered Capitalism? If Capitalism is definitively unfettered, then, there is no such thing as unfettered Capitalism, because if you fetter it, it is no longer Capitalism. Of course, that's my definition, which may disagree with yours. Normally, when you hear terms like unfettered Capitalism, unrestrained commerce, the "dictatorship" of the free market, etc., you are likely listening to someone who has been soaked, stewed and steeped in Marxist theory. In America, this Marxist anti-Capitalism sentiment is interwoven into virtually all formal education.
Unrestrained consumerism at the individual level, is, of course, harmful, as is almost anything over-indulged in. Over-indulgence in just about anything harmful begins with over-indulgence in consumerism. But, as in all things, that is a matter of the moral struggle between vice and virtue. Our religion teaches us to moderate our appetites; however, note well that Marxism attacks also our religion. In America, this Marxist anti-religion sentiment is interwoven into virtually all formal education.
The fall-back position of the unfortunate citizen who encounters hardship is the charity of the family, the charity of the Church and the charity of like-minded neighbors. Again, note well the fact that Marxism attacks also the family, and that this anti-family sentiment is interwoven into virtually all formal education.
There is nothing left out of the Marxist demonizing of things. Inheritance. Private property. All in favor of the eventual great collective, in which everyone on earth is equal and holds all property in common, and there is no government.
The impracticality of the whole thing approaches the level of the imbecilic. It takes my breath away, to consider that any adult capable of critical thinking could ever believe that anything like a global collective of equal people holding everything in common in the absence of any governing authority is even remotely possible.
First, how do you gather everything? Then, how do you distribute everything? Then, how do you keep doing it?
Well, you don't. It is quite impossible.
What can I say?
Every bit of Marxist ideology is blithering idiocy.
And there ain't no such thing as Unfettered Capitalism.
Sarcastic Acronym Hover-Link Footnotes: For the convenience of those readers using devices that lack a mouse, these footnotes are provided for all webpages, in case any webpage contains any hover-links. (If you don't have a mouse, you can't "hover" it over a link without clicking just to see the simple acronym interpretation. Click any footnote link to see the acronym and a detailed explanation.)SLIMC1 Secularist Liberal Intellectual Media Complex
The Brilliantly Conceived Organization of the USA; Vic Biorseth
Return to the BLOG page
Return to the HOME PAGE
Subscribe to our Free E-Zine News Letter
Respond to This Article Below The Last Comment
Date: Wed Aug 20 2014
From: Vic Biorseth
Changes pursuant to changing the website URL
and name from
Thinking Catholic Strategic Center to
Catholic American Thinker.
Pulled the trigger on the 301 MOVE IT option June 1, 2014. Working my way through all the webpages. .
Date: Tue Sep 11 01:17:06 2018
From: Liberal Atheist (I know you'll love that)
"There is no such thing as unfettered Capitalism, because if you fetter it, it is no longer Capitalism." This makes no sense to me. So because cigarette companies are fettered with restrictions that prohibit advertising on TV or selling to minors, they're not free to make money? Because automobile companies are fettered with emission standards, they're not free to make money?
Date: Tue Sep 11 2018
From: Vic Biorseth
Your Marxism is showing, in that you are confusing the argument between Capitalism and Communism with the desire to perfect Creation through forcible government action. Which is another argument altogether, between Freedom and Communism.
I know, Marxism can be confusing, and Capitalism is generally too simple for Marxism's convinced Useful Idiots to grasp, steeped as they are in elitist and supposedly intellectual Marxist complexities. In answer to your questions, cigarette companies and car companies could still produce profit, but not as much, and perhaps not enough depending on payroll and other business expenses.
Capitalism is all tied up in four natural law rights of man: Equality, Life, Liberty and Property. They are treated separately, in Equality, Life, Liberty and Pursuit of Happines. In America, these four natural law rights are all Constitutional Rights of the American citizenry.
The one you need to look at and try to understand is the Pursuit of Happiness, or, Property, because Property = Wealth = Profit, all the very things demonized and hated by Marxists and today's Marxist-infected "Liberals". All the very things that made America a great nation. All the very things suppressed in Socialist lands, making them poor, at the citizen level.
Your Liberal Atheist dream of a one-day perfect world wide collective or cooperative community of happiness is a pipe dream. A deception. Perfection is not of this world, but the next.
Never be lukewarm.
Life itself demands passion.
He who is indifferent to God has already forfeited his soul.
He who is indifferent to politics has already forfeited his liberty.
In America, religion is not mere window dressing and citizenship is not a spectator sport.
Do not allow our common destiny as a whole people to just happen without your input.
Seek the Truth; find the Way; live the Life; please God, and live forever.
Catholic American Thinker
Free E-zine Subscription
You will receive immediate email newsletters with links to new articles as they are published here. Your email is perfectly secure here; we use it only to send you the
Catholic American Thinker
and absolutely nothing else.
Enter ye in at the narrow gate: for wide is the gate, and
broad is the way that leadeth to destruction, and many there are who go in
thereat. How narrow is the gate, and strait is the way that leadeth to life:
and few there are that find it! Beware of false prophets, who come to you in
the clothing of sheep, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.
Jesus Christ; Matt 7:13-15
This group of links
show articles exposing the infiltration of evil into the Church, larger
Christianity, the American government, Political Parties, the larger
Culture, and Western Civilization
The Infiltration of Evil Pages
Showing how Evil advances in culture by one little "accommodation" at a time, to the point where supposedly good men of high stature eventually come to support it under other names, through corrupted language.
On Cultural Desensitization to Strategies of Cultural Destruction. The systematic psychological desensitization of a nation's citizenry to the reality of mortal threats to nations.
The Infiltration of Evil Pages highlight the hidden advance of our cultural destruction. Mighty nations, invincible in battle, may be taken down by slow parasitic infiltration of evil.
On the Coming Total Global Reset. This Global Reset will touch every aspect of human life, and nothing will be the same again.
Gay Marriage: What the hell is gay about it? It isn't Gay Marriage, it's Homosexual Marriage. If you surrender the language you lose.
Disorder and Confusion from the White House. And from the Vatican, too? The growing disorder in Obama's America, and in Pope Francis' Catholic Church.
The "Top Down" Catholic Revolution by Bishops Against Established Doctrine. The "Bottom Up" Catholic Revolution by Laymen For Established Doctrine.
Anathematizing anathema: the predictable result of the denial of evil. In a world that denies the existence of evil, anathematizing anathema itself is the only anathema allowed.
On Glorious Adult Judgmentalism, and Our Disastrous Loss Of It. The desire to "Find Common Ground" precipitates our slow, steady, sure decline into pure evil.
The Grand Conspirators, gathering riches and power through treachery and deceit. The Grand Conspirators behind collapsing currencies, environmental panic, social revolution and the end of nations.
Farewell America? No friendly nation will bid "Farewell America" as we go under, for all friendly nations will be too preoccupied with their own deadly emergencies.
American Faith: What it was in the beginning, what it is now, what it should be. If Modern American Faith is not to be Christian, then, what exactly is it to be? Nothingness?
The cultural road to Sodom: Wide, smooth, straight and downhill all the way. Asking the questions, is America already the New Sodom, and is there any way back to simple decency?
Property = Wealth = A Penny Saved = A Fundamental Human Civil Right. Wealth Redistribution = confiscating private property from those who earned it to benefit those who did not earn it.
What does income inequality, or any inequality, have to do with morality? When did we become so stupid? Income inequality, wealth gaps, etc., are not moral issues.
Imperfect Cliven Bundy v. all the Perfect White Commentators. Perfection is not of this world, but the next; unless you're a White Journalist, Pundit or Commentator.
The Class Warfare Lies of "Social Justice" infecting theology and philosophy. Most every time Social Justice is invoked, you are about to hear some Class Warfare Lies.
Decision Point: Will You (We) Stand in Truth, or Lay Down with The World? The exact same Decision Point at which Nineveh was saved, and Sodom and Gomorrah were lost.
On Common Law and the Constitution. What, exactly, is Common Law?
The Contraception Perversion: The Deep Root Cause of All Sexual Perversions. Every form of sexual perversion has its roots in the original perversion of Artificial Contraception.
How many "Practicing" Catholics are really only Lip Service Catholics? Lip Service Catholics like to look Catholic and sound Catholic, but they are fraudulent Catholics.
"Unfettered Capitalism" does not exist; so why is the term so popular? Unfettered Capitalism is a nonsensical term. The moment it is fettered it is no longer Capitalism.
Do detractors even know what Trickle Down economic theory is? Those who condemn Trickle Down economic theory either don't understand it, or they are trying to fool someone.
Marching nations into the Great Collective under the banner of Social Justice. Does Social Justice mean collective property, collective labor, collective rights and collective salvation?
Presenting Yankee Economics to Ranking Catholic Churchmen and others unfamiliar. Yankee Economics 101: A light description for those who never experienced it.
Wayward bishops and complicit journalists corrupted Catholic culture. Evil grew as a leaven in the clergy and corrupted Catholic culture from within.
Establishment Democrats, Establishment Republicans, and Establishment Bishops? Supposedly Catholic, Inside-the-Beltway, Big Government, Progressive, Establishment Bishops.
On the Objective Reality of God, Objective Reality versus Subjective Empiricism, which holds that Reality is subject to Human Perception.
Death to the Church of Nice. Long Live the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church.
Religion in Culture: the vitally important factor no longer recognized today. Secularists oppose religion in culture. But then, secularists oppose both religion and culture.
Cardinal Dolan's Church of Sodomy: destroying New York Catholicism from the top. Cardinal Dolan is doing to New York Catholicism exactly what Comrade President Obama (peace be upon him) is doing to Constitutional America.
The Culture of Death always wears a false but alluringly innocent smiley face. The Culture of Death, where Madam Hillary loves Scripture and your Living Will won't necessarily kill you.
Thinking of Bai MacFarlane and the upcoming Synod on the Family. Whatever emanates from the Synod, the Bai MacFarlane family tragedy brings it all into proper focus.
Incremental Tyranny advances as we Tea Party-ers cheer our imagined victories. How we always greet more Incremental Tyranny with a cheer, a whoop and a happy-dance.
Catholic American Treason: Bishops join Republcrats in Obamunist treason. Bishops participate in the destruction of American sovereignty, in acts of Catholic American Treason.
On The Evil One's Mal-Formed Compassion and Malignant Mercy. In malignant mercy we see that evil and untruth can infiltrate and commandeer even the virtues.
Promoting Moral Depravity: the popular sport of the intellectual elites. Almost no one knows they are promoting moral depravity, but almost everyone is.
The Pathological Liars of the Left. What do common criminals, Marxists and Moslems have most in common? They are all pathological liars.
Disinformation differs from miss-information by being deliberate and deceptive. Deliberate Disinformation moves America and the World deeper and deeper into error.
Evil is, definitively, Falsehood; Evil is the Opposite of permanent Truth. Evil convincingly argues Religion out of Politics in this temporary, passing world, where Satan reigns.
On the Stupidity of Evil, and the Connection between Evil and Stupidity. Evil is Opposition to God, and Opposition to God is just Glaring Stupidity.
Truth Denial: Über-elitist, high intellectual, super sophisticated Stupidity. Evil = Falsehood; the opposite of Truth. It is not possible to oppose reality and not be stupid.
"We belong to the Church militant; and She is militant because on earth the powers of darkness are ever restless to encompass Her destruction. Not only in the far-off centuries of the early Church, but down through the ages and in this our day, the enemies of God and Christian civilization make bold to attack the Creator’s supreme dominion and sacrosanct human rights.”--Pope Pius XII
"It is not lawful to take the things of others to give to the poor. It is a sin worthy of punishment, not an act deserving a reward, to give away what belongs to others."--St. Francis of Assisi
Truth is incontrovertible. Malice may attack it, ignorance may deride it, but in the end, there it is.—Winston Churchill
The smallest minority on earth is the individual. Those who deny individual rights cannot claim to be defenders of minorities.—Ayn Rand
If you can't find the page you're looking for, try the